Thick and slippery
For full disclosure, we received the BUTTR Fisting Gel Water-based Lubricant to review as part of the vine program.
Firstly I was very impressed by the size of the container when it came, it is a large pot and feels very industrial in black. When opening the pot I was at first a little unimpressed, as at first glance it does appear to just be a large tub of normal water-based lube, but there are a few differences in use.
As you can see from the second photo I have attached the lube is VERY thick, it easily clung onto my finger and would take a while to drop off. This gives it a really nice consistency to work with, and the fact that the pot has such a wide opening makes it very satisfying to reach in and get a complete fistful.
Firstly we tried this out using silicone toys and this was the weakest area for the lube, when using it with toys, especially anally, we found that the lube even when used very liberally seems to dry out or disappear rather quickly, so you need to make sure you keep applying lots to compensate.
When it came to using this with a fist is where the lube really shines and it is clear why it is marketed in that way. The thickness of the lube in combination with the amount the pot encourages you to use makes for effortless insertion and a very wet and fun time. We did not find it to dry out the same way as when we tried with toys.
The only other thing I would like to mention is that it is very important to store the pot upright, as it is so thick and the hinge on the pot goes all the way back meaning if any gets stuck in the lid whilst it is open then it can leak out the back of the hinge